What does your game reward, and what does that tell your players the game is about? We look at where that question comes from in game theory and gamification, what the Forge years had to say about fun, and the social rewards a table builds on its own.
We start with the rewards many of us learned first. XP and gold in D&D came out of zooming in on a character in Chainmail, and gold turns out to be hard to run well when someone has to balance an economy around it. From there we get into rewards aimed at who a character is, like karma in Marvel, beats in Chronicles of Darkness and nature in Vampire.
Then we turn to explicit goals, and that means beliefs in Burning Wheel, keys in Shadow of Yesterday, the worked examples in Cypher, and Freemarket, where advancement comes out of changing the story. We talk about why belief writing is hard, why a goal built on failure can be the interesting one, and how goals can expose that a campaign is not about what you thought.
We give the cons their time too, from optimization pressure to beliefs that sit unused on a sheet, and Scott talks about giving up sole responsibility for where the story goes.
For more on the discussion of System and Style check out our written articles and Scott’s additional thoughts on specific systems on our YouTube channel.
Topics discussed:
00:01:58 Game theory, gamification and dopamine loops
00:05:28 The Forge, GNS and “bad fun"
00:09:15 XP and gold in D&D
00:13:13 Gold economies and alternate reward systems
00:16:41 Roleplay rewards: karma, beats, nature
00:20:05 Exploits, milestones and rules authority
00:25:44 Implicit rewards and D&D's wargame roots
00:31:06 Playing against the system's incentives
00:34:58 Explicit goal systems and prep authority
00:39:06 Belief writing, failure goals, buy-in
00:45:30 Freemarket and Cypher goal systems
00:50:55 Narrative drift and games off-rails
00:55:26 Knowing a character before its goals
00:58:13 GM control and inciting incidents
01:03:38 Prescriptive play and optimization pressure
01:10:54 Intrinsic motivation and fragmented parties
01:13:43 Giving up sole narrative responsibility
01:15:51 Epilogues, downtime and session openers
01:19:11 Angles, random tables and session zero